Doctoral research is normally thought of as a lofty and mentally stimulating endeavour. But beneath the mental ideal lies a collection of personal and social weights which doctoral students silently bear. Among them are the most significant marital expectations, familial responsibilities, and resulting guilt over life occurrences postponed. The problems are particularly severe in collectivist societies, wherein family interdependence is the guiding principle of life decisions.
The graduate life, longer and longer, more indefinite, financially insecure, is an incubus into which are poured the social roles, gender roles, cultural expectations, and economic need. It is a time-consuming, peculiarly unrewarding experience. Most of them are in tension with a personal crisis between what they want and what is expected of them, and therefore experience emotional trauma, strained relationships, and the looming sense of guilt.
Read More: The Weight of Expectations: How Family Pressure Can Lead to Stress
Socio-Economic Pressures and Delayed Milestones
Poor and middle-class students, in particular, face a series of socio-economic pressures. Doctoral study is a lengthy and peculiarly unrewarding endeavour. Here, as in South Asia and Africa, there is no institutional support, the stipends are meagre, and the rising cost of living compounds them. For example, Levecque et al. (2017) carried out research where it was found that PhD students are most likely to be vulnerable to developing mental illness disorders, and financial insecurity is one of the foremost contributing factors.
While doctoral courses demand unwavering commitment, the rest of the world still imposes conventional demands such as early marriage, economic contribution to the family, and maintaining gender-specific roles. The pressure is more acutely felt by the female candidates. In man-dominated cultures, marriage during or immediately following their doctoral course is the preferred time. Delaying marriage for the sake of education is generally frowned upon and can lead to social boycott or manipulation.
Families may implicitly—or openly—encourage the student to forego a life partner or Ph.D. Neither are men exempt; they may be encouraged to be breadwinners earlier, especially if siblings or friends are already working. Procrastinated economic independence with continued financial dependence or underpayment leads to feelings of inadequacy and failure on both the personal and societal levels.
Read More: PhD in India: The Hidden Mental Health Struggles and How to Cope
The Double Burden of Academic Shame and Family Pressure
Amongst the most common emotional responses that doctoral students have in these situations is guilt. Academic guilt exists in a complicated package: it develops due to spending less time with family, being unable to take care of older parents, or being an economic burden. This pressure also increases when students see friends marry, secure jobs, or engage in adult activities they must delay.
The emotional weight of familial duty is too heavy to handle when added to the loneliness of a scholar’s life. In most instances, scholars are culpable of becoming academics, a career some deem self-indulgent or overly pampered compared to other “practical” ways of living. Pyhältö et al. (2012) in their described study established that PhD students tend to feel isolated and emotionally distressed due to tensions between social expectation and academic identity. This isolation not only affects mental well-being but also academic underachievement or attrition.
Besides, family responsibility can be associated. Parents may initially take pride in the scholarly pursuits of their child but see support wane with time, especially if doctoral periods are long or unrelated to real-time revenues. This sets the paradox in place where students owe families emotionally and economically, and therefore the guilt and rather the justification for academics.
Read More: Academic Pressure on Higher Studies and Its Impact on Students’ Mental Health
Cultural Narratives and Gendered Pressures
We cannot overemphasise the role of the cultural narrative of family expectations. Family members are not only support groups in collectivistic societies like India, China, and parts of the Middle East, but also stakeholders in individual decisions. People view marriage as a family accomplishment rather than an individual one. In India, to be precise, families and society routinely describe female physicians in their late twenties as “overqualified” or “too old” for suitable matches. Chakraborty and Subramaniam (2021) describe the way Indian academic women face the double stigma of being ‘too ambitious’ and ‘not familial enough.’
Men also experience gendered expectations, but in a slightly different manner. Families usually expect them to “settle down,” become homeowners, or maintain stable incomes before deeming them suitable for marriage. Going for a PhD, particularly in the social sciences and humanities, where financial rewards are less, tests these norms. This tends to create tension in family relationships, with parents doubting the sustainability of academic professions.
These stories put the students in emotionally vulnerable spots, having to continually negotiate their identity: as scholar, child, partner, and prospective parent. The tension of doing well academically while preparing at the same time for a culturally viable future leads to chronic stress and emotional exhaustion. This chronic tension compels many to downplay their scholarly ambitions or rush into marriages that are not necessarily in their best interest emotionally or intellectually.
Read More: The Weight of Expectations: How Family Pressure Can Lead to Stress
Marital Issues During and After Doctoral Studies
Doctoral students who marry during their studies experience special difficulties. People often say that marriage should provide stability. Instead, it can become another source of tension. Academic calendars, away times for fieldwork, long hours of research, and mental burdens of scholarly writing can stress even the most supportive relationships. When both spouses are academics, publication pressures, funding rivalry, and geographical moves because of postdoctoral opportunities can be sources of strife.
Conversely, when a partner is not academic, comprehending the requirements of a PhD can prove challenging, creating miscommunication and failed expectations. Martinez et al. (2013) discovered through a study that marital PhD students frequently find it challenging to manage spouse duties as well as academic productivity, and this is more so for women. Moreover, childcare duties, especially for women, contribute to increased dropout rates or extended graduation timelines. The institutional disregard of family-friendly policies further exacerbates such conditions.
Doctoral students routinely end up making trade-offs: delaying children, deciding jobs based on partner location, or even declining opportunities in the interest of marital bliss. People inevitably make these trade-offs at the personal and professional level, and they add to the sense of guilt towards oneself, one’s aspirations, or one’s family.
Read More: Mental Load in Relationships: What it is and Why it’s often invisible
Institutional and Policy-Level Gaps
A major cause for the ongoing stress in doctoral students is the absence of systemic support. There is a general lack of financial support in most academic institutions, especially in low- and middle-income countries, to enable them to live independently or support their families. Many of these institutions provide no mental health services, or they integrate them inefficiently into academic work.
There is no maternity/paternity leave, spousal accommodation, or on-campus childcare arrangement available for doctoral students in most universities, placing added pressure. Even where policy exists, cultural stigma keeps students from accessing it. The academic culture tends to celebrate suffering and overwork, so that students find it challenging to complain or ask for help. There is a culture of silence in doctoral environments regarding such personal troubles.
Based on a Nature survey in 2019, over 36% of global doctoral students said they had received help for depression or anxiety, with pressure to perform well in their studies, financial pressures, and family stressors as top reasons. Until institutions of learning embrace a more integral definition of student well-being that includes familial and socio-cultural aspects, this vicious cycle of guilt, pressure, and emotional depletion will not cease.
Read More: Gender Norms and Self-Concept in IndiaÂ
Challenges Ahead: Reframing Success and Support Systems
In the future, the challenges will be more so. More and more students are pursuing doctoral studies around the world, particularly from non-traditional sources, which means that academic and personal life will increasingly collide. The gig economy, academic precarity, and global economic crisis only add to the pressure on students who now have to not just produce a PhD but also contend with a job market that provides fewer full-time positions.
There is also an increasing necessity to redefine success in academia. Instead of defining success as continuous scholarly pathways, single-minded dedication, and geographical mobility, institutions and funding agencies need to acknowledge the validity of alternative life choices and timelines. Universities should mainstream the marriage and parenting of doctoral students and institute mechanisms like flexible deadlines, family accommodation, and spouse career support.
At the policy level, fellowships and scholarships need to have inclusions of married students, parental leave, and family health insurance. Social narratives also have to change so that the concept of education and marriage are not necessarily mutually exclusive, and that intellectual pursuits are not selfish desires but investments for the long term in the development of society.
Read More: Deadlines and their Negative Impact on Workers’ Mental Health
Conclusion: A Call for Compassionate Academia
The doctoral path is not merely an intellectual endeavour; it embeds an intensely human experience within intricate social realities. Marriage, family pressure, and academic guilt are a set of tensions that continue to impact doctoral students everywhere, especially those with socio-economically underprivileged or culturally conservative backgrounds. These intersecting sacrifices require a humane and inclusive scholarly culture—a culture that recognises the student outside of their scholarship, acknowledges them as a whole person with rich personal lives, and offers institutional and emotional support scaffolding to facilitate them.
Real change will entail micro and macro interventions—everything from reframing family dialogue about success and timelines to reimagining institutional policies that make room for varied life trajectories. Only then can we build educational spaces in which students are free to flourish intellectually without having to forfeit their emotional and family well-being.
FAQS
1. What are the major challenges faced in pursuing a doctorate?
As a doctoral student, an individual faces the challenges of finding proper funding schemes or scholarships, proposing a suitable thesis, a lack of proper guidance and the imperial edge taken over him/her by the guide.
2. Why is it necessary to bring about a change in the statistics of pursuing a Phd in India?
Due to a lack of opportunities and the pressure associated with pursuing a good career, the tendency of people going ahead with a Phd has dropped significantly, emphasising the need for a change due to future chances of reduced manpower resources and brain drain
3. How does the PhD process in India turn out to be hectic and time-consuming?
Phd as an academic endeavour has its challenges of indulging in extensive research and a lack of funding. Thus, the process turned out to be hectic and time-consuming.
Leave feedback about this