Can You Trust Someone Behind a Screen? The Psychology of Catfishing
Relationship

Can You Trust Someone Behind a Screen? The Psychology of Catfishing

can-you-trust-someone-behind-a-screen-the-psychology-of-catfishing

“Can I trust someone behind a screen?” In a world where most of everyone’s life is on a technological device, it was just a matter of time before relationships took that jump. Nowadays, six billion people are connected to the internet worldwide (Thompson and Thompson, 2025). Also, people have become dependent on technology and the web in order to keep everything in order and under control. Even romantic relationships. People have found a way to connect with others through the website, texting, video calls, apps, profiles and social media. But what happens when that convenient and fast space is not what someone expects? What if the person behind a profile that seems perfect is not? Then a person can be in front of an online catfish. 

What is an Online Catfish? 

Nowadays, being online is a normal aspect of life. As a matter of fact, it’s commonly said that if someone doesn’t have an online presence, it is like someone doesn’t exist. With that environment, it’s not a strange phenomenon that relationships also went to an online context. The possibility to connect with people around the world in minutes and the opening of multiple social media platforms and messaging web services, as well as the freedom to open a profile or get a user on messaging websites, has allowed that. 

But another aspect that came with it was online scams. One particular area of scams is Internet dating scams. In that case, a person can steal someone else’s pictures, usually of attractive people, and pretend to be that person to meet others. The relationship will show increasing affection and promises of meeting while the scammer begins to ask for small gifts or money. It can end up in an encounter, and the victim might choose to continue the relationship for fear of abandonment and deception (Coluccia et al., 2020). 

The term catfish was born in a TV show on MTV, but to put it as a concept, catfish in the online world is a form of online deception and fraud. A person might engage in a relationship, or more than one, with others using an alternative false identity (Ryan and Taylor, 2024; Campbell &  Parker, 2022). This can happen in any online place, but according to research, the most common is social media. Facebook and Instagram are the most used for catfishing, followed by Twitter (now  X). (Ryan and Taylor, 2024). 

Read More: Liking vs. Loving: When Does Affection Become Love?

Behind The Screen: Motivations for Catfishing 

Researchers suggest that the motivations behind catfishing could be intrinsic. For example, two reasons found in research were exploring the self and being unrepresentative of oneself (Ryan and  Taylor, 2024). In other words, the reasons found for catfishing were that a person was exploring their personality and identity, as well as acting according to an ideal representation of oneself instead of reality. 

Nevertheless, it needs to be considered that those researchers weren’t considering another factor. For example, the economic aspect of the phenomenon. Campbell and Parker (2022) explored another set of possible motivations. What they found is actually a match to previous research about how catfish tend to be male, with higher education. 

But they also found two other important factors. One is religiosity, since individuals in catfish relationships can explore romantic connections without social pressure or judgment. And the second one was impression management and narcissism. People with impression management tend to change aspects of themselves to suit the context. Individuals with these characteristics can use them to their advantage in order not to lose the other person in the relationship (Campbell and  Parker, 2022). 

And narcissism. Since the internet does not work with the same rules and regulations as the outside world, there can be little to no consequences for what is done in the online world. Catfishers report not feeling guilty about the deception they commit. The lack of empathy and being able to manipulate, deceive and exploit romantic partners are characteristics associated with narcissists  (Campbell and Parker, 2022). 

Read More: 4 Signs of Hidden Tension in a Relationship 

Lying Online: Profile Editing  

The online world can give any person the opportunity to control how they present themselves, and that can create the opportunity for deception. Dating apps and webs allow for the users to  select profile pictures, descriptions and personal information that can focus on particular parts of  the person. Online daters actually manage their presentation actively in an attempt to manage attractiveness with the expectation of meeting potential partners (Ellison et al., 2006). That behaviour shows how a person can be edited in digital environments. 

But the identity edition doesn’t only stop focusing on the person’s best features. Toma et al.  (2008) also found that people can provide inaccurate information about their age, height, weight and even photographs. Even in cases where the inaccuracies were small, the findings show how anyone can build an identity different from the current one. 

Going deeper into the editing of someone’s profile, deception can go from lying about the colour of the hair to being taller, thinner. But in more serious cases, it shows how easy it is to build and personify an entirely new person. If an online relationship evolves and becomes closer and even gives the perception that someone knows the one behind the screen, there is no guarantee that that person is being honest with the other. 

Read More: The Psychology of Unspoken Expectations in Relationships

Emotional Consequences of a Catfish Relationship 

When initiating a relationship, any person has expectations, but if a relationship ends up badly, the person can suffer from deception. In the case of catfish relationships, that is not an exception.  Victims of online dating romance scams reported having a “double hit”. On one hand, they might experience financial losses and, on the other hand, also emotional loss. Some of them described that the emotional loss was worse than the financial one (Whitty and Buchanan, 2016). 

The end of a relationship that includes a scam can also involve another emotional consequence.  Romance scam victims reported feeling shame, distress, acting impulsively, and having problems trusting others (Whitty, 2018). Victims of online catfish probably will have to deal with betrayal, loss, embarrassment and feeling uncertain about their own decisions.

Read More: Beyond Betrayal: Understanding the Mental Health Factors Behind Affairs

Protect Yourself: Warning Signs and Grooming 

One of the internet dangers for users is grooming, and it can also show a clearer view of why online deceptions can be convincing. When an online relationship is happening, grooming can be seen in the form of fraud and deception in which the other person exploits the expectations of the other about love and trust (Feng, 2026).  Following that path of behaviour, some warning signs in an online relationship can be: finding inconsistencies in someone’s information, avoidance of opportunities to meet or communicate, an unusually rapid development of emotional intimacy, and requests for money, gifts or financial aid. But all of those should be taken carefully.  Some ways to protect yourself from a catfish, in front of those warning signs, can be: 

  • Verify the information of the person 
  • Talk to others about the relationship (family and friends) 
  • Avoid sharing sensitive personal or financial information 
  • Don’t send money or gifts 

Conclusions

Online relationships, like any other online phenomenon, can have risks. One of those is encountering an online catfish (someone who creates a false identity to deceive another person into having a relationship). Online profile lies can go from changing a few features about oneself,  such as physical aspects, to the creation of a new nonexistent person. In some cases, the person falling into a relationship with a catfish not only faces an emotional loss after finding out about the deception, but can also face financial losses. 

Although it is impossible to avoid the potential risk of meeting people online, people can take steps to protect themselves. Some of the steps that can be taken include: talking to trusted friends or family, verifying information about the person, avoiding sharing sensitive information such as personal information and financial information and mostly never sending money or gifts to someone unknown.  

Ultimately, catfishing reminds people that behind an online profile there can be someone the other doesn’t fully know. And for a moment is valid to think about how easy is to create an identity online but that needs to come with the reminder that the matter is not how easy someone can trust another person behind a screen but how careful someone has to be to trust them.

References +
  • Campbell, K., & Parker, M. L. (2022). Catfish: Exploring the individual predictors and interpersonal characteristics of deceptive online romantic relationships. Contemporary Family Therapy, 44(4),  422-435. 
  • Coluccia, A., Pozza, A., Ferretti, F., Carabellese, F., Masti, A., & Gualtieri, G. (2020). Online romance scams: Relational dynamics and psychological characteristics of the victims and scammers. A  scoping review. Clinical practice and epidemiology in mental health: CP & EMH, 16, 24. 
  • Ellison, N. B., Heino, R., & Gibbs, J. (2006). Managing impressions online: Self-presentation processes in the online dating environment. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 11(2),  415–441. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1083-6101.2006.00020.x 
  • Feng, M. (2026). Grooming in online dating romance frauds and scams: A scoping review. Journal of Economic Criminology, 13, 100231. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconc.2026.100231 
  • Ryan, S., & Taylor, J. (2024). An exploration of the motivations of catfish perpetrators and the emotions and feelings expressed by catfish victims using automated linguistic analysis and thematic analysis. Discover Data, 2(1), 6. 
  • Thompson, A., & Thompson, A. (2025, October 15). Digital 2026 Global Overview Report – We Are  Social UK. We Are Social UK. https://wearesocial.com/uk/blog/2025/10/digital-2026-global overview-report/ 
  • Toma, C. L., Hancock, J. T., & Ellison, N. B. (2008). Separating fact from fiction: An examination of deceptive self-presentation in online dating profiles. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,  34(8), 1023–1036. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167208318067 
  • Whitty, M. T. (2018). Do you love me? Psychological characteristics of romance scam victims.  Cyberpsychology, Behaviour, and Social Networking, 21(2), 105–109. https://doi.org/10.1089/cyber.2016.0729 
  • Whitty, M. T., & Buchanan, T. (2016). The online dating romance scam: The psychological impact on victims, both financial and non-financial. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 16(2), 176–194.  https://doi.org/10.1177/1748895815603773
...

Leave feedback about this

  • Rating