How Does Metacognition Work? The Science Behind Thinking About Thinking
Awareness

How Does Metacognition Work? The Science Behind Thinking About Thinking

how-does-metacognition-work-the-science-behind-thinking-about-thinking

In everyday life, most of our time is spent in thinking and learning which further requires to remember, be decisive, and solve problems that may arise. The question that comes to mind is how often do we actually pay attention to what we are thinking? How often do we examine our thinking patterns? Metacognition is the awareness of one’s own thinking. Simply put, it’s “thinking about thinking.” The concept of ‘what one might know or not know’, recognising both the scenarios by monitoring the thinking and changing the approach as required is involved in metacognition (Flavell, 1979). This is important because just having knowledge about something is not enough to result into successful thinking. It also depends on being aware about how to use, observe, and adjust that knowledge (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020).

Read More: Psychological Insights into Metacognition and Learning

What Does It Mean to be Metacognitively Aware

Metacognition is defined as the awareness and understanding of one’s own thinking, which could further involve the ability to monitor and regulate it (Schraw & Dennison, 1994). Metacognitive awareness starts with understanding one’s own cognitive abilities. It involves cognitive strengths, limitations, tasks at hand, and strategies available (Flavell, 1979). 

For instance, an individual may be familiar with a theory they think they understand. But they realise that to explain the concept of the theory they require to take a peek into their notes. The realization they have is the metacognitive awareness. This basically implies their familiarity with the information is not the same as having full understanding of the concept. Therefore, for an individual metacognitive awareness can be explored through certain questions, such as,

  • What does one already know?
  • What does one struggle with?
  • What strategy is being used?
  • Is it actually working?
  • What should be changed or adapted instead?

These set of questioning can actively initiate the process of learning. It can further lead to an understanding of how one’s mind learns in the best way possible (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020).

Self-Monitoring: Watching the Mind at Work

One of the most useful and central parts of metacognition is self-monitoring. The observation of one’s own cognitive processes while it is taking place is referred to as self-monitoring. It basically evaluates thoughts and action in real-time. Self-monitoring is a continuous process of evaluating thoughts and performance, while also responding to the internal and external information (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020).

Let’s assume an individual practising a dance routine. They somehow get stuck on one of the dance steps in middle of the routine. If the individual carries on with the rest of the dance routine without acknowledging the issue, they are ineffectively monitoring their performance. An individual with metacognitive awareness on the other hand would pause, reflect, and adapt to a different strategy. This would eventually lead them to produce their best routine by adjusting their error (Epstein et al., 2008). Self-monitoring can help recognise certain patterns that could influence behaviour in people, such as,

  • errors
  • biases
  • emotional reactions
  • unrealistic self-assessments

This distinction is important because just by observing any short-comings or failure is not the same as monitoring. It offers insight that can further guide towards the next action (Nelson & Narens, 1990).

Read More: The Fog of Worry: How Anxiety Affects Self-Monitoring and Decision Awareness

From Monitoring to Self-Regulation

Self-regulation boosts awareness and makes it useful. According to the demand of a situation, changes in the behavioural responses both cognitively, or emotionally is involved in self-regulation (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020). 

The process of self-regulation is quite similar to the executive functions which includes cognitive adaptability, working memory, and inhibition (Hofmann et al., 2012). There are processes such as goal setting, forming strategy, self-evaluation, and seeking assistance which are involved in a self-regulated learning. Therefore, this leads to metacognition being not just about awareness of a thought but also the realization of acting upon that thought (Zimmerman, 2002).

For instance, there is a presentation and the individual is preparing hard, byhearting everything there is to be presented and needs to be memorised. But as they go on with the preparation, they find out that the recall of material is lacking. As the realisation hits them that the recall is not taking place as desired, they switch up their strategy. The concepts are broken down, those concepts are understood by them rather than just memorised, and they finally explain it all as intended to be presented. This is called metacognitive regulation where-

  • The learning was monitored.
  • The strategy was judged.
  • Finally, the behaviour was modified (Nelson & Narens, 1990).

Read More: Self-regulation Tips for People with Anxious Attachment

Cognitive Strategies: Knowing What to Do

There is an involvement of cognitive strategies in metacognition and choosing them appropriately. Strategies (Flavell, 1990) are the tools used to process information, such as, 

  • summarising, 
  • organising information, 
  • questioning oneself, 
  • making connections, 
  • practising retrieval, or 
  • breaking a difficult task into smaller parts.

In the cognitive monitoring model (Flavell, 1990) the strategies are included along with knowledge, goals, and experiences one has. The most basic point to understand is that a single strategy is not applicable to all scenarios. An individual faced with a complex problem might require to proceed in a strategic manner,

  • First comes the need to define the problem
  • then to identify the available information
  • which could generate possible approaches
  • later monitor the progress
  • lastly, evaluate the final solution.

There is an educational value of this process which is supported by research (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020). A meta-analysis that was conducted examined the interventions curated to promote self-regulated learning. The findings showcased advantages for building strategy, motivation, and overall academic performance (Dignath & Büttner, 2008). 

For instance, an individual attempting to master a particular skill they want, would have to be aware about how much they have learned. This is possible when they ask themselves in terms of where do they stand in utilising the skill they are practising. Then moving onto if they can actually convey or showcase it to someone else or even teach it to them. This could help them evaluate whether any learning has taken place on their end. Also, the progress they have made and if there’s any need to have change in approach, is all practically possible through metacognition.

Metacognition in Everyday Problem-Solving

The concept of problem-solving naturally involves metacognition. For an individual to solve a problem they require to identify the actual problem and proceed to evaluate it through different strategies to reach to an outcome (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020). 

Let’s consider an individual who arrives late to the office almost every day. Simply thinking to be on time won’t necessarily be the most effective approach. Although it is the most natural thought to occur in such a scenario. Realising and becoming aware of how reaching on time is directly influenced by preparing the previous night changes the solution. They may realise they have nothing prepared in terms of meals or clothes, procrastinate to shower, and even forget to charge their phone on time. Through this metacognitive reflection the individual may find a solution to their problem.

This highlights an important principle associated with problem-solving. It is that an effectively better problem-solving begins with a better definition of the problem. In case a problem gets misunderstood, it could cause even the best strategy to work ineffectively towards a solution (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020).

Metacognition in Everyday Decision-Making

Metacognition can, to certain extent influence decision-making process. An individual may indulge in scrutiny of all the possible assumptions associated with a choice or a decision (Efklides, 2006).

For instance, an individual is out shopping for clothes and have a slightly different style in mind they want to purchase. It is a form of styling that is more modern than what they usually wear. Before even deciding to buy, they assume the worst of it in case people judge them. But they can eventually counter this through metacognitive thinking. It provides another approach which points towards if there is any evidence for such a belief. This creates a small boundary between the thought and the decision (Drigas & Mitsea, 2020).

Can Metacognition be Learned?

The most obvious applications of metacognition are in education. Effective learners not only absorb information. They practice self-regulated learning involving continuous monitoring and controlling of their learning. Studies have found that metacognitive knowledge instruction and its effectiveness is valuable across varied academic subjects (Donker et al., 2014).

Metacognition is not simply to be considered a permanent personal characteristic. It can be developed through deliberate practice (Tanner, 2012). A simple metacognitive routine for an individual can be:

  • Before: What is my goal? What do I already know? Which strategy should I use? 
  • During: Am I understanding this? Is my strategy working? 
  • After: What worked? What did not? What should I change next time? 

Even though they may appear simple, these set of questions encourage learners to become observers of their own learning (Tanner, 2012). Without the need to depend entirely on external solution, individuals gradually develop the ability to identify and address their own difficulties.

Self-regulated learning research demonstrates that the learning improves when individuals intentionally handle their learning objectives, strategies, and self-evaluation. Metacognition is more than just an academic skill. It’s a strategy to make our learning, problem solving, and thinking to be more intentional (Zimmerman, 2002).

Conclusion

Thinking about thinking can be abstract, but it is a regular occurrence. To know facts is beneficial, but to consider and employ one’s own thinking can make it more effective. It is present when a student realizes that re-reading isn’t providing any help, when a person asks a question before making a choice, or when a person realizes that an older strategy no longer works.

The gap causing thought to be separated from action is due to metacognition. It enables us to track what we know and identify our gaps, choose strategies to improve, and adapt our actions. It isn’t intended to have control over our thoughts. But to become more aware of how our thinking works and being more intentional about what we do with it.

References +
...

Leave feedback about this

  • Rating