Log Kya Kahenge? The Psychology of Shame and Guilt in Indian Society
Social

Log Kya Kahenge? The Psychology of Shame and Guilt in Indian Society

log-kya-kahenge-the-psychology-of-shame-and-guilt-in-indian-society

India as a society is collectivistic, which means that every action comes from a group discussion. This group is none other than one’s immediate family, peers, workplace, neighbourhood etc. What makes the society unique is that people are driven to preserve and maintain high morals but when these morals become too rigid to follow it gradually starts creating shame and guilt among individuals. For instance, when an individual wants to marry someone of their choice but the family does not agree for it, the individual is then trapped in this cycle of shame and guilt. Shame and guilt are such that they bring the happiness, risk, joy, and independence at stake. This article aims to explore the shame and guilt culture in India, what is the primary reason for it, how it impacts the individual and society as a whole. 

Read More: Neural Differences Between Guilt and Shame: How These Emotions Shape Behaviour

Understanding the Shame and Guilt Culture in India

The very first attempt in explaining shame and guilt culture was done by Eugene Nida an Anthropologist in his textbook Customs and culture (1954). In his book he discusses how a sense of shame is expressed in statements like, “I’d feel terrible if anyone saw me doing this”, guilt expressed in the inner feeling of failure for not meeting the expectations set by the society. Although his explanation has a limited scope, it sets a way to understand the shame and guilt culture of society(Cozens, 2018). Paul Ekman, a psychologist, describes shame and guilt as basic emotions which individuals experience. When does this shame and guilt start impacting society ? In order to understand this, it is important to consider what culture truly means.

Edward Taylor a sociologist and an anthropologist explains culture as a way of life which includes, language, tradition, custom, food, and every other habit which a man had imbibed in himself as being a member of the society(Rao, 2009). Considering cross culture Asian societies are more likely to be driven by shame than the western societies. The section below explains the analysis on how this culture manifests in Indian Society. Not all parts of Indian society are driven by shame and guilt but it unevenly prevails in the society. 

Read More: The Guilt–Shame Cycle: How Body Talk in Indian Families Shapes Self-Worth

A Psycho-Social Analysis on the Reasons behind this Culture

  1. The Complexity : According to Mele (2017), a guilt culture is a society where guilt is created with the inner feelings of guilt associated with certain condemned behaviour, practices, or thoughts. Indian society rightly fits this explanation because the feelings of guilt are such feelings which are internally driven. Whenever an individual has to make a decision which is only going to benefit him but not his family it is most often seen that the individual will never take an action towards such a decision. The feelings of guilt are strongly internally rooted. 
  2. Pride and Oneness : Mele (2017), furthermore explains that shame is most often associated with pride and honour. When some mishap happens to take place the entire society first thinks about the societal image rather than paying attention to the victim and their loss. The sense of pride is also associated collectively. For instance: Dialogues or statements are often said to threaten individuals that if they do something wrong the entire family will have to suffer. Pride is also shared. 
  3. A Warrant – Shame and Guilt : According to Tracy et al., (2007), shame and guilt are seen as something which are obligated in society. In a society like India, when individuals are bold and take a stand for themselves they are most often labeled as shameless and someone who is selfish. On the other hand when an individual makes decisions which are not beneficial to him but  are to the society they are considered as god-like figures. Most often individuals face problems in making independent financial decisions. It can also be said that shame and guilt are compulsory factors of Indian Society.
  4. Extrinsic Social Surveillance :  It is also known as fear of judgment. Most of shame and guilt stems from having fear of judgement. Constant thinking and rumination about the values, morals, ideals set by society lead to the development of fear of judgement. Even if one decision is making an individual happy their first thought would be what would society think about me ? Individuals most often feel that they are under surveillance and somebody is always monitoring their actions. 
  5. Perfectionism : This quality is intrinsic in nature. Some individuals seek perfection in life where they want to get admired by others. They at times tend to follow and promote the rigid values of the society. Perfectionism also stems from fear of judgement, the need to fit in the standards of the society.  According to Karen Horney the need for admiration is one of the neurotic needs which drives individuals to work perfectly(Schultz, 2017).   

Read More: The Psychological Effects of Living in a Surveillance Society

The Impact of Shame and Guilt Culture on Young Adolescents

Shame and guilt have their own consequences on adolescents especially during the crucial identity formation years. Adolescents are vulnerable and need time to understand their transition. Shame and guilt is experienced by many adolescents in multiple contexts. Adolescents experience shame and guilt when they do not fit in the beauty standards of the society, when they are unable to determine their sexual orientation or feel confused about it, adolescents also feel guilty if they sleep excessively in today’s times this act is often referred to as ‘Sleep Shaming.’Many a times adolescents feel left out among their peers if they are unable to withstand the pressure, competition.

All of this leads to multiple consequences on mental health. Gradually, adolescents start accepting this as normal and imbibe shame and guilt within themselves. They experience an identity crisis and end up accepting the rigid norms of the society. They also then want to struggle a lot or work more than necessary in order to glorify their hustle(Shweder, 2003). 

Contemporary Society

According to Patel (2018), the traditional mechanism to regulate the behaviour i.e., shame and guilt have weakened. He suggests that neither external social pressure nor individual morality is sufficient; rather, socialization and education can be the right medium to develop moral consciousness. He states that shame and guilt culture can be eliminated when right moral values, ethical reasoning, personal responsibility and respect for social obligations are developed and imbibed in an individual. This research paves the way between traditional rigid norms and modern thinking.

Furthermore, he emphasizes that socialization and education are the right and safe ways to transmit moral values. There should be a rational and secular based approach to value education. In gist, the researcher lays emphasis on the role of education, internalised moral standards, and personal responsibility to foster moral values within contemporary Indian society. This view can be well connected with the above mentioned analysis of shame and guilt culture in India.

As members of society many times individuals are not allowed to question the usual norms and are made to follow them but this can be changed in the contemporary times with healthy socialization and education. Socialization and education would enable the members of society to overcome the association of pride, honour and surveillance.   

Conclusion

Shame culture refers to the behaviour which is regulated by social approval, reputation, and the fear of disapproval from others whereas the guilt culture refers to the behaviour which is regulated by an internal sense of responsibility. Guilt and shame should be exercised and taught in moderate amounts. Excessing them  leads to consequences. In a society like India which is collectivistic in culture, moral values, ethics, social rules and norms should be taught properly rather than forcing them on the new generation. If any questions or curiosity comes up it should be addressed rather than ignored. Shame and guilt lead to feelings of anxiety, inferiority, lack of self esteem and efficacy.

References +
...

Leave feedback about this

  • Rating