Educated, Employed, and Still Expected to Bear a Son: The Gender Paradox in Modern India

The deeply ingrained cultural tradition of India is central to understanding the historical roots of its gender roles. For centuries, a patriarchal system has defined clear roles, with ancient Vedic texts from as early as 1500 BCE privileging men in both social and spiritual domains. While women were often confined to domestic work, men were positioned as the primary providers.

Although the colonial era introduced legal reforms to improve women’s rights, such as banning sati and regulating child marriage in the 19th century, these changes often coexisted with deeply rooted patriarchal customs. As Condorelli (2015) explains, despite improvements in education, traditional customs continued to weaken women’s status.

Following independence, India’s constitution granted equal rights to all citizens, but traditional socio-cultural expectations, such as the practice of dowry, persisted, creating a struggle between constitutional protection and entrenched patriarchal ideologies. As Costagliola (2021) notes, traditional perceptions of women’s roles have remained strong since 1947, reflecting the persistent conflict between tradition and modernity.

A Battle of Norms: Tradition vs. Modernity

In contemporary India, the social environment is governed by an intricate mix of old-fashioned mindsets and emerging social transformations. The patriarchal systems remain strong, producing sharp-cut stipulations for individuals. Women are most often viewed through the lens of domesticity, with a common presumption that their identities revolve around care-provision and home upkeep.

As noted in Costagliola (2021), this expectation complicates the entry of women into the labour market, with many citing home responsibilities as a primary barrier to employment. Even with the growth of female literacy and employment participation, enormous gaps continue to exist in societal attitudes towards individuals. This is especially evident in arranged marriage settings, as women are frequently pressured to accept traditional roles while their male counterparts are more independent (Mukherjee, 2024).

Marriage itself often reinforces these gendered conventions; women are socially conditioned to set aside personal aspirations to foster family cohesion, often at the expense of traditional power dynamics (Mukherjee, 2024). Furthermore, cultural patterns such as dowry payment and son preference continue to be dominant, reflecting deeply ingrained biases toward male survival at the expense of female survival (Condorelli, 2015).

Urban lifestyles may be more liberal in their attitudes toward gender roles than rural ones, but the contrast is striking, with traditional norms continuing to influence communities everywhere in India. This is one such case of a society attempting to cope with modernisation while maintaining traditional practices that shape gender identities.

Investigating Gender Expectations

1. The Weight of Traditional Roles

Traditional gender roles in present-day India continue to dominate the socio-cultural space and influence expectations put on women and men. Traditionally, these roles have been shaped by patriarchal ideologies that dictate a woman’s place in the home and society. Women are largely expected to do household work, care for children, and manage family relationships, while men are expected to be providers and disciplinarians. This gendered division of labor exists in both rural and urban environments, albeit in different forms.

The practice of arranged marriages is a pragmatic manifestation of these prevalent expectations. For example, brides are often viewed as commodities exchanged between families on their wedding days, which reinforces the perception of women as subordinate to men (Mukherjee, 2024). Beyond this, cultural expectations deem women “flexible,” requiring them to be subservient to their husbands’ desires at the cost of their own career aspirations (Mukherjee, 2024). Such forms of coercion can silence women and shatter their dreams within their own homes.

In addition, these stereotypical gender roles act as barriers to women’s professional development and labour integration. Despite the substantial improvement in women’s education, cultural perceptions still limit their career opportunities based on entrenched stereotypes of what they should do (Naznin Tabassum, 2021). The consequences of such fixed roles not only negatively impact women’s mental health but also create entrenched imbalances that hinder true gender equality in India.

2. A Tale of Two Indias: Urban vs. Rural Trends

Urban and rural gender roles differ significantly in contemporary India. Urban areas are gradually shifting toward more non-stereotypical gender roles as a result of education, employment, and global cultural influences. Women are increasingly pursuing higher education and white-collar jobs, moving away from traditional home-front constraints (Evans & Jonathan Evans, 2022).

Rural societies, however, tend to adhere to tradition-bound gender roles due to cultural and economic factors. Agriculture and home management are often the only options available to women, and limited opportunities for quality education and employment dissuade innovation (Sahrakorpi & Bandi, 2021). Rural women also face distinct challenges, such as limited mobility and social pressures, that deter them from activities outside the home.

Organisations like social enterprises or microfinance programs attempt to empower them, but with mixed success. They may gain economic independence in a few cases, but in others, they encounter severe barriers to social acceptance (Sahrakorpi & Bandi, 2021). Urban locations, therefore, witness changing gender norms while rural locations remain under the influence of traditional practices that have a strong hold on women’s lives.

Psychological Consequences

1. Impact on Mental Well-being

The societal pressures mounted on women in present-day India have the potential to make a substantial impact on their mental well-being. While attempting to juggle the intricacy of time-honoured duties and contemporary social expectations, most face mounting stress and anxiety levels. Traditional feminine roles typically require them to become the family caregivers and a source of family well-being, but at the same time, encourage them to acquire an education and build professional careers.

This dual expectation can lead to role strain, where women feel burdened by the competing demands of meeting family obligations and working toward success on a personal and professional level (Sharma et al., 2016). In urban life, this pressure is intensified since societal demands deem autonomy and success as the highest values. However, this comes with significant expense to their mental health; workplace and home multitasking can be frustrating and lead to feelings of inadequacy and self-doubt.

Women are said to suffer from depression and a lack of confidence as they juggle these competing demands (Weaver, 2020). And on top of this comes the stigma attached to mental illness, which prevents women from getting aid or even voicing their anguish. This complex interplay of cultural expectation and personal aspiration is a challenging context wherein women’s mental health is jeopardised.

The tension linked with unfulfilled expectations can manifest both physically and psychologically, presenting potentially long-term health problems if left untreated. The psychological implications are grim, signalling the need for increased public awareness and support systems geared to meet the specific needs of women in modern-day India.

2. Identity Conflicts and Self-Image

Women in contemporary India grapple with issues of self-image due to the tension between traditional gender expectations and current aspirations. They struggle to reconcile the demands of cultural expectations with pursuing education and professional growth, creating conflict as they attempt to be caring caregivers and professional career people.

Commercial surrogacy exemplifies this dilemma; while economic independence brings empowerment to some surrogates, several express feelings of exploitation and insufficient autonomy in choice-making (Rozée et al., 2020). Cultural conceptions link the worth of a woman to family needs rather than to career goals. Caregiving women tend to be stretched by conflicting demands, impacting their health and identity (Sharma et al., 2016).

The obligation to fulfil these roles leads to internalised shame and reduced self-esteem when their accomplishments fall short of ideal societal expectations. Sustaining gender stereotypes within the domestic sphere and workplace also restricts opportunities for promotion (Naznin Tabassum, 2021), reinforcing women’s identity conflicts and requiring reassessments of their roles in the family and society.

Intersection with Education and Work

1. Education Level vs. Job Opportunities

In modern India, the relationship between educational levels and opportunities for jobs is significantly affected by gender disparities. Even though there is a rise in women’s enrollment in schools, this achievement does not translate into corresponding job opportunities. Women are greatly deterred by societal attitudes and prejudices from securing jobs equivalent to their qualifications.

Scheduled castes and groups are also further burdened by gender biases and socio-economic reasons, which limit equal access to quality education and work (Dunn & Dunn, 1993). Even the more educated fare worse in the labour market than men, along with an increasing gender wage gap that serves as a deterrent to employment (Klasen & Lamanna, 2009).

Conventional gender roles also complicate it, since educated women typically divide their careers and domestic responsibilities (Naznin Tabassum, 2021). While the cities offer better circumstances, rural areas cling to traditional standards restricting the involvement of women in the labour market (Costagliola, 2021). Without implementing policies to narrow this gap, the economic empowerment of women remains limited even with rising levels of education.

2. Women’s Challenges in the Workplace

Despite growing numbers of women on the job, impediments continue to face their professional development and equality. Traditional gender roles in Indian patriarchal society typically reserve caregiver jobs for women, marginalising their ambitions. Women are discriminated against in hiring and have limited opportunities for career development.

Research from Cook (2020) confirms that educated women acquire only 70% of what male employees earn, pointing toward stereotypes concerning women’s capability to work. Workplaces can become hostile or violent based on stereotypes and discriminatory practices. Myburgh et al. (2025) urge organisations to conduct gender analyses to see how policies can be used to perpetuate inequality and suppress women’s growth.

Without supportive programs, like family-friendly work arrangements, it becomes tougher for them to balance work and household roles. Women also experience harassment and physical abuse in the workplace, with a resultant high turnover and poor mental health. Although there is a move toward inclusion, various initiatives remain unfinished and fail to address intersectional challenges faced by marginalised women (Dunn & Dunn, 1993). Systemic reform to bring about gender equality at work is required.

Shattering Stereotypes: Real-Life Stories

1. Case Studies of Educated Women Balancing Roles

In modern India, working women are forced to face professional aspirations colliding with societal expectations. Priya, a software engineer in Mumbai from a middle-class background, is under pressure to get married and have a child despite her professional success. Though encouraging, her parents worry that she is getting old without a marital tie, an articulation of traditional gender conceptions. Conversely, Aditi, a rural Bihar teacher, represents the change.

While education enabled her to excel, social barriers limited her own goal aspirations due to family demands. Her case illustrates the role strain, demonstrating how social pressure adds stress (Sahrakorpi & Bandi, 2021). Social enterprises such as Husk Power Systems (HPS) provide important platforms for women who are both parenting and working.

Local women workers in HPS manage production alongside domestic duties, enhancing economic resilience within their households. However, this type of work tends to entail a “choiceless choice,” excluding real empowerment (Sahrakorpi & Bandi, 2021). These testimonies reveal the long-standing challenges of well-educated women against the backdrop of evolving opportunities.

2. Success Stories in Exceeding Expectations

In contemporary India, women are more and more shattering gender stereotypes in society, unlocking opportunities for empowerment and achievement. One of the best examples of this movement is the initiative driven by Husk Power Systems (HPS) in rural Bihar. Through the recruitment and training of local women for jobs in mini-grid projects, HPS not only offers them secure employment but also boosts their status in society.

This move is consistent with the organisation’s purpose to empower women as a means to deal with broader social inequalities, hence promoting economic and societal development (Sahrakorpi & Bandi, 2021). Another compelling tale emerges from the entrepreneurship scene, where women entrepreneurs are making tremendous progress.

The rise of start-ups founded by women has proved conspicuously prevalent in urban India, spurred by initiatives meant to build up women entrepreneurs. As more women seek patent filings and startup enterprises, they continue to experience persistent imbalances (Chatterjee & Ramu, 2018). These pathbreakers are not merely shattering social stereotypes but also mentoring future generations.

For example, women from diverse backgrounds have established ventures that serve women or that aim to solve problems in their localities, marrying personal aspirations with social good. These examples point to how even in the face of persisting challenges, Indian women are transcending gender constraints by taking drastic steps to reengineer their roles in society and positively contribute to economic growth.

Paving the Way: Policy and Ethical Issues

1. India’s Journey Toward Gender Equality

India has embraced a series of policies aimed at promoting gender equality, reflecting an enthusiasm for the empowerment of women across various sectors. A milestone was reached in 1993 with the signing of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), aligning national efforts with global criteria for gender equality.

Additionally, programs such as Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (Save the Girl Child, Educate the Girl Child) and the Mahila E-Haat online market platform have been initiated to empower women through education and enterprise. But there are still very challenging issues. For instance, political representation of women is remarkably low; only 14.7% of Lok Sabha seats are occupied by women as of 2024, which indicates extreme underrepresentation in decision-making positions (Mehta, 2024).

Moreover, even with laws to prevent gender-based violence and discrimination, enforcement remains weak. According to Mehta (2024), crime against women is on the rise, particularly in rural areas where deep-seated traditional culture inhibits progress. Also, India’s policy environment is usually lacking in the integrated intersectional examination it needs.

Research has shown that transportation and urban mobility policy tends to overlook the distinctive needs of women (Kakar et al., 2021), thereby hindering their ability to access essential services and economic opportunities. A better, more integrated policy framework with gender-sensitive strategies is necessary to bring about sustainable change. In conclusion, although India has made significant progress toward gender equality through various programs, there remain gaps in implementation and representation that need ongoing reform and stronger enforcement mechanisms.

2. The Road Ahead: Recommendations for Change

To address gender inequalities in India, policy must focus on key recommendations. Making existing laws stronger and applying them with a firm hand against gender violence and harassment at the workplace is the first step, as highlighted in section 7.1. To understand how women’s experience is shaped by caste, class, and geography, an intersectional view is needed. Such reforms ought to be the foundation of policy change.

Despite women achieving higher levels of schooling, prevailing stereotypes still restrict the labour market. Future campaigns must fund gender-transformative schooling, empowering women and challenging stereotypes early enough. It is crucial to determine the special problems of rural women. Entrepreneurial skill-building programs and economic support for entrepreneurship need to improve their economic opportunities.

Mentorship initiatives that connect successful women with aspiring girls can further facilitate this goal. Transportation policies must incorporate women’s safety and mobility, as Kakar et al. (2021) argue. Enhancing public transport will enable women to participate in education and the job market. Lastly, implementing quotas to enhance the political representation of women will ensure that decision-making includes their voices.

Conclusion

India’s gender roles, influenced by centuries of patriarchal tradition, persistently struggle with a complicated and gradual evolution. Constitutional laws guarantee equal rights, but deeply entrenched socio-cultural mores establish a wide gap between legal protection and everyday life. This makes it a double burden on women, as they negotiate the conflicting demands of traditional roles and modern expectations, resulting in high mental health issues, conflict over identity, and restricted career avenues.

The dramatic contrasts between the urban and rural spaces, where change is more obvious in the city but the old mores continue to hold in the villages, underline the unevenness of the transformation. Even with these difficulties, women all over India are challenging the gender conventions actively, emerging as successful businesswomen, and joining the labour force in ways unheard of before.

Though government initiatives and policies work towards ensuring gender equality, the abiding gaps in implementation, political representation, and enforcement mean that achieving parity of the sexes is still a long way off. Ultimately, this journey will need to take on a multifaceted nature that not only enforces stronger laws but also insists on an intersectional analysis of women’s experiences and education and economic empowerment to chart the way towards an equally balanced future.

FAQs

1. How does gender bias affect women in STEM and high-skilled industries in India?

Despite increasing education levels, women in science, tech, and engineering face hiring discrimination, limited mentorship, and workplace exclusion. Deep-rooted stereotypes about women’s technical abilities continue to marginalise them in these high-growth, high-paying sectors.

2. What role do Indian men play in either maintaining or challenging gender roles?

The article focuses on women, but change also requires men to challenge patriarchal norms. Male allies in homes, schools, and workplaces must actively support gender equality, sharing domestic responsibilities and opposing cultural practices that limit women.

3. How does media representation influence gender perceptions in Indian society?

Mainstream media often reinforces traditional gender stereotypes, portraying women as caretakers or victims. Positive, diverse representations of empowered women in films, television, and advertisements are crucial to reshaping societal expectations and challenging outdated norms.

4. Are LGBTQ+ individuals affected by the same gender norms discussed in the article?

Yes, though the article focuses on cisgender women, LGBTQ+ individuals face compounded discrimination. Traditional gender roles rigidly define acceptable behaviours. They often exclude and marginalise queer identities in both rural and urban India. This creates additional layers of vulnerability.

5. What is the role of religion in reinforcing or challenging gender expectations in India?

Religious texts and interpretations often reinforce patriarchal roles. However, progressive religious scholars and activists are reinterpreting these doctrines. Their aim is to advocate for gender justice. The intersection of faith and feminism remains a powerful yet complex space for change.

6. How do climate change and environmental stressors impact gender inequality in India?

Climate-related issues disproportionately affect women, especially in rural areas, where water scarcity and agricultural instability increase their domestic burdens. Women’s limited decision-making power in environmental policy further marginalises them in climate resilience planning.

References +

Alessandra Costagliola. (2021). Labor Participation and Gender Inequalities in India: Traditional Gender Norms in India and the Decline in the Labor Force Participation Rate (LFPR). https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s41027-021-00329-7

Diya Mehta. (2024). India’s Gender Policy: Successes, Shortcomings, and the Way Forward. https://www.risingpowersinitiative.org/publication/indias-gender-policy-successes-shortcomings-and-the-way-forward/

Andrew Myburgh, Hiromichi Katayama, Susan Lund, Stefania Giannini, Borhene Chakroun, Farid Fezoua, Pablo Fajnzylber, Amy Luinstra, Chris McCahan, Emelly Mutambatsere, Mattia Olivari, Allegra Colombino, Chiara Burastero, Dina Nicholas, Bertrand Momo, Sanola Alexia Daley, David Mena, Geoffrey Sanzenbacher, Morten Lykke Lauridsen, Charlotte Portes. (2025). Closing the Gender Gap in Education and Employment. https://www.ifc.org/content/dam/ifc/doc/2025/closing-the-gender-gap-in-education-and-employment.pdf

Dana Dunn. D.. (1993). Gender Inequality in Education and Employment in the Scheduled Castes and groups of India. https://libres.uncg.edu/ir/uncg/f/D_Dunn_Gender_1993.pdf

Jenna Cook. (2020). Educational Disparities Among Girls in India. https://ballardbrief.byu.edu/issue-briefs/educational-disparities-among-girls-in-india

Naznin Tabassum.Bhabani Shankar Nayak. (2021). Gender Stereotypes and Their Impact on Women’s Career Progressions from a Managerial Perspective – Naznin Tabassum, Bhabani Shankar Nayak, 2021. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2277975220975513

Rosalia Condorelli. (2015). An emergentist vs a linear approach to social change processes: a gender look in contemporary India between modernity and Hindu tradition. https://springerplus.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40064-015-0933-7

Inayat Singh Kakar, Margaret Peden, Jagnoor Jagnoor. (2021). Intersectionality based policy analysis: Equity in mobility in India. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0967070X20309276

Sreya Mukherjee. (2024). Swipe Right for Tradition: Decoding Gender Constructs in Modern Indian Matrimony through Media Representations. https://cgsjournal.com/v1/n1/v1n108.pdf

Chirantan Chatterjee, Swapnika Ramu. (2018). Gender and its rising role in modern Indian innovation and entrepreneurship. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0970389617305694

Lesley Jo Weaver. (2020). Sugar and Tension: Diabetes and Gender in Modern India. https://somatosphere.com/2020/sugar-tension-weaver.html/

Stephan Klasen, Francesca Lamanna. (2009). THE IMPACT OF GENDER INEQUALITY IN EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC GROWTH: NEW EVIDENCE FOR A PANEL OF COUNTRIES. https://chicagopolicyreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Gender-and-Economic-Growth.pdf

Jonathan Evans, Jonathan Evans. Neha Sahgal. Ariana Monique Salazar. Kelsey Jo Starr and Manolo Corichi. (2022). How Indians View Gender Roles in Families and Society. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2022/03/02/how-indians-view-gender-roles-in-families-and-society/

Tiia Sahrakorpi, Venkata Bandi. (2021). Empowerment or employment? Uncovering the paradoxes of social entrepreneurship for women via Husk Power Systems in rural North India. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629621002462

Virginie Rozée, Sayeed Unisa, Elise de La Rochebrochard. (2020). The social paradoxes of commercial surrogacy in developing countries: India before the new law of 2018. https://bmcwomenshealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12905-020-01087-2

Nidhi Sharma, Subho Chakrabarti, Sandeep Grover. (2016). Gender differences in caregiving among family caregivers of people with mental illnesses. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4804270/