Research

Research Explores How Body Posture Shapes Risk-Taking Behaviour and Influences Mood

research-explores-how-body-posture-shapes-risk-taking-behaviour-and-influences-mood

The way someone sits and where they carry their body has always struck one as simple. However, new science shows that our bodies can influence our feelings and choices, without realizing it, in times that promote sitting in a device-overworking, remote work, environmentally fluid manner. To see if the many ways that environmental factors influence our Body Posture can affect our confidence and the ways we assess risks, the scientists at McGill University researched environmental factors that push us into sitting in specific physical attitudes and then wrote this up in the British Journal of Psychology. At their heart they ask an easy question, can an upright posture affect our feelings and decision-making?

To preface the individual techniques and results, it’s also worth placing this research in the wider field of ’embodied cognition.’ While some of the research on the original “power poses” (suggested the act of expansive stance helps one feel more powerful) drew criticism due to issues around demand characteristics and uncertain replicability, these researchers tried to counter by attempting to have participants naturally assume particular postures with little in the way of participants being explicitly instructed to adopt a “pose” this means the results are a valuable indication of how actual ergonomics like desk height could influence our everyday lives. 

Relationship Between Mind and Body

The central psychological assumption underlying this investigation is a conception of the mind-body linkage that is bidirectional and recursive, namely that our bodily postures can signal back into cognitive and emotional processes. This notion is frequently described under headings such as embodied cognition or postural feedback in which posture acts as an input into the emotion and cognitive process rather than solely an output (as in slumped dejection). To that extent, postures have broadly been viewed in two categories: “expansive” (standing tall with back straight, chest broad, and aligned). Body Posture is associated with openness and pride, and expansive postures can produce these effects. The converse has been claimed for” contractive” (hunched, closed and stooped) poses, thought to be the posture of a low mood, low self-confidence and a sense of inferiority and subservience. 

There are two primary effects addressed by the research from McGill: mood and its correlate feeling pride and risk-taking. In the case of pride, it is not taken to be related to the kind of hubris that some psychologists may distinguish from mere arrogance and is used to represent the kinds of good feelings that one can have about one’s own accomplishments rather than the more formal “self esteem.”

Instead, risk-taking, as reflected by whether posture affects one’s optimal decision-making choices regarding potential losses versus potential gains, is examined, not any sort of random abandon. By relating body posture to both emotions, mood, and behavioral decision-making, it should communicate basic psychological effects to lay readers and relevant clinicians, teachers, or office-space designers.

Read More: Thrill or Resilience – Exploring Risk-Taking Behaviour

Experimental design

How Body Posture Shapes Mood and Behaviour is reported by Soren WainioTheberge and Jorge Armony of McGill University, with results appearing under the title of ‘Manipulating posture implicitly through environmental constraints influences mood and risk-taking behavior’ in the British Journal of Psychology. The article describes a sample of almost 200 McGill community participants, which seemed adequately sized to detect even small but significant changes.

Participants had originally been introduced to the experiment as working to ‘test a mobile app.’ In reality, the mobile app story was a blind tool designed to distract participants from the hypothesis the researchers were exploring about postural influences. It was very important to ensure that participants wouldn’t simply behave the way they ‘thought the researchers wanted them to behave’! 

The researchers altered their physical setup to change Body Posture rather than giving direct instructions. In the condition where a tablet was positioned on a stand on a high table, which adjusted naturally in height, people assumed a more erect seated position, their heads and necks more aligned than in the contractive condition, where a tablet lay flat on a low desk and led people to bend forward and be slouched over.

They were then given a computer task requiring a certain level of risk-taking known as the Balloon Analogue Risk Task (BART), where money can be made by inflating a virtual balloon, but everything is lost if it pops. Along with measures of people’s behavior during the task the researchers obtained data from questionnaires about how they were feeling, including pride, as well as used software to measure their neck angle as a proxy for posture. 

Correlation between body posture and risk-taking behavior

They found that participants adopting the upright, broad position made riskier, but more adaptive, decisions in the balloon task, earning more on average. Notably, this does not appear to have stemmed simply from a need to act but seems to reflect a calculated strategy to calibrate risk in order to obtain a greater reward, suggesting that posture may, to a degree, even enable higher performance in decision-making with uncertainty. It also fits with general embodiment research indicating that positive affective states may facilitate processing and decision-making performance. 

Emotionally, participants in the upright condition experienced significantly more pride, suggesting that this intervention was effective in increasing positivity and the level of positive mood and self-esteem. Interestingly, Body Posture had an indirect effect on pride; that is, the size of the posture’s impact on participants’ mood was dependent on how much their necks bent over (level of neckflexion). This was called posture and had been shown to be both a modulator of mood and associated with the effect of posture on behavioral decisions by the researchers. In a single experiment, they found modest but significant results related to behavioral and affective differences caused by differences in posture. 

Read More: The Psychology of Bodily Kinaesthetics: Harmonizing Body and Mind

Looking through the author’s lens

The authors believe that this experiment offers new proof that incidental postural posture-as by computer, desk height, or ergonomic layout-the type the are inclined to encounter day after day, may be at work impacting disposition or danger–taking behavior with out conscious understanding. “Opposite to lots of the earlier ‘energy present’ literature, not only are we not asking individuals to stand or adopt any positions ourselves, but post-experiment interviewing indicates that our members weren’t even conscious they stood or sat in any respect a lot differently,” they wrote, “a measure of decreased demand character.” 

And this is an important but subtle effect recorded in the lab; we don’t expect we will be able to greatly change our lives simply by sitting up straight. However, according to both authors, their findings are important in pointing to the fact that subtle properties of our surroundings might have a persistent and more or less silent influence on our moods and our strategic calculations. Clinicians and psychotherapists, the new results are consistent with growing evidence that sitting upright helps promote a positive mood and positive self-regard even when the individual is stressed. 

Employers and designers should note that this study lent more support to the idea that ergonomics encompasses not just the comfort of your back and muscles but the functionality of your mind as well. These findings support the notion, in embodied cognition theory, of creating models of decision and emotional processes in which the body becomes incorporated. 

Conclusion

When combined, the McGill study implies that the postural postures, constructed in natural environments by easy means such as placement of your desk, computer, or smart device, might have subtle effects of facilitating or mitigating your sense of self-esteem, mood and executive risk taking skills. A participant who was slumping at their laptop was less likely to be proud or to perform successfully in an economic simulation task in a lab, while a posture of openness (such as expanding the chest and limbs) and openness led to better performance – none of this occurred even if participants were unaware that their postures were being recorded or taken note of.

The Bottom Line on How posture, a purely skeletal issue, is actually a cognitive issue that has ramifications for emotional well-being, task performance, and decision-making in real life. It goes without saying that sitting straighter, alone, is unlikely to solve pressing clinical issues. However for more targeted concerns, paying attention to position may be a relatively low-effort, low-cost method to bolstering mood and enabling more reasonable risk taking, both at home and at work, at school, and in the therapist’s office. For the scientifically inclined, it suggests bringing the role of bodily states into fuller consideration in our theories about emotion and thought; For the general reader, the message could be a modest yet important take-home point: How we sit, you see, could just as easily affect how we act. 

References +
Exit mobile version